The Benefits of Short Lessons in
the Charlotte Mason Method
The idea of short lessons is often approached with skepticism by parents.
I understand this completely as I was a doubter myself. I have often asked
parents this question, “Do you have anything to lose by trying it? If you
were to try short lessons and find they did not work for you, couldn’t
you just go back to long lessons?” I cannot even count the number of parents
who tried this and now rave about short lessons.
One of the most common complaints I hear from moms and dads about home
schooling is the amount of time it can take a child to complete fairly
straight forward subjects such as math. Charlotte Mason used an old fashioned
term, dawdling. What I find is that the children are unconcerned and frankly
could not care less about dawdling, in other words it does not bother them
in the least. I cannot exactly explain why children seemingly prefer to
sit and doodle, stare into space and try every trick in the book just to
stall and waste time. But I do know this—it is the parent who cares, who
is concerned, who would strongly prefer to start a lesson or topic and
finish it in a timely way.
Short lessons help to get the child’s attention and that appears to be
half the battle. Mason put it this way, “You want the child to remember?
Then secure his whole attention,” Home Education. (Vol. 1, p. 156) Her
definition of attention is summarized as “the whole mental force is applied
to the subject in hand. This act, of bringing the whole mind to bear, may
be trained into a habit at the will of the parent or teacher, who attracts
and holds the child’s attention by means of a sufficient motive.” (p. 145)
Moms and dads want to know how to do this. What is our part in getting
the child’s attention? How can we help the child to want to buckle down
and concentrate?
One way to help with this is by recognizing the power of habit and how
that can work to our advantage. The formation of good habits is one of
the crucial teachings of Charlotte Mason. Although it is not our topic
in this article it does apply to our use of time in our school day. Charlotte
teaches us that adults should not waste time and neither should children.
One very practical way to teach this is to set the example. Mason told
parents to teach their children that there is “satisfaction to do the day’s
work in the day, and be free to enjoy the day’s leisure.” Ourselves (Vol.
4, part 1, p. 173) What that means in the 21st century is this: If you
have work to do whether it is grocery shopping or laundry, you can try
to goof off and have fun and somehow pretend that you do not have anything
more pressing to do, but it rarely works. For instance, I am working on
the computer right now when perhaps I would rather be outside walking or
enjoying a hobby. But the truth is, if I finish my work now I can truly
enjoy my fun time later today. If I play and have fun now the joy of it
will be somewhat lessened, because I will have my undone work on my mind.
The power of attention is a very useful resource for any person to develop.
As a parent, you want your children to listen to and retain the information
you communicate to them. Charlotte Mason once pointed out that educated
professionals such as lawyers for example have to be able to listen (pay
attention) and react. “Contrast this with the wandering eye and random
replies of the uneducated;—and you see that to differentiate people according
to their power of attention is to employ a legitimate test.” (Vol. 1, p.
137) Do not depend upon a sudden decision on the part of the child to start
paying attention. Depend upon habit. If your children are still young and
you are interested in Charlotte Mason’s philosophy then I recommend you
read her first volume all the way through as soon as possible. You will
find by reading it that these habits can and should be started in infancy.
It is the parent who can help the children to play with one toy for a little
longer span of time than they would have without your guidance. Train the
children at a young age to really look at things.
When they get older, “never let the child dawdle over a copy-book [penmanship]
or sum, sit dreaming with his book before him. When a child grows stupid
over a lesson, it is time to put it away. Let him do another lesson as
unlike the last as possible, and then go back with freshened wits to his
unfinished task...the lesson must be done, of course, but must be made
bright and pleasant to the child.” (Vol. 1 p. 141)
In the Charlotte Mason method we always vary the lessons to keep it fresh
and to avoid boredom. It is invigorating to go from math to poetry, from
penmanship to history. Choose the school subjects so that they alternate
between routine practice and subjects that take serious thought. With each
day’s schedule we would want to vary the order somewhat to avoid any drudgery
of a strict routine.
If the word schedule makes your blood run cold then give me a moment to
prepare you. Clearly there are structured home schooling families and relaxed
unschooling families and every possible combination in-between. It is my
firm belief that anyone will be able to strike a balance while still happily
leaning toward the side they are most comfortable with. A strict “school
at home” parent could benefit from borrowing some key ideas from the unschooling
method. And the ultra relaxed unschooling parent could benefit from utilizing
a small amount of structure. Why? Do we need to be balanced for balances’
sake? No, not really. The better answer is because some parents, as they
lean too strongly toward one extreme or the other, wind up either in heavy
burnout from too much structure or in unbearable guilt from not achieving
their own home schooling goals. Chronic guilt is no way to live. It is
a burden and many feel the need to hide it from everybody. There really
are moms who have not covered fairly important educational areas and they
see the years going by one by one. I know because they have met with me
and shared the pain of guilt that they have successfully kept hidden from
their friends.
Moving on, the CM method does include the posting of a schedule. This would
include what to do and how long each lesson will last. She writes, “This
idea of definite work to be finished in a given time is valuable to the
child, not only as training him in habits of order, but in diligence; he
learns that one time is not ‘as good as another’; that there is no right
time left for what is not done in its own time; and this knowledge alone
does a great deal to secure the child’s attention to his work. Again, the
lessons are short, seldom more than twenty minutes is length for children
under eight.” (Vol. 1, p. 142)
Short lessons consist of 15 to 20 minutes in length during elementary school.
They increase to 30 minutes per subject in junior high and to 45 minutes
in high school. Remember, the CM students were in school six days a week,
and they were covering 15 to 21 subjects per week (not per day) even as
early as seven and eight years of age. If you need additional time for
any subject because you only home school four days a week, you may want
to add another short segment at some other time in your day or weekend.
You can also try teaching some of the material that will be new to the
child during other times and then using short lessons for practicing what
they do know.
Now you can see why I prepared you--this does not sound much like unschooling
does it? A method that includes the posting of a schedule, which should
indicate what to do and how long each lesson will last, has helped my home
schooling experience and in fact makes it so that I can unschool all afternoon,
evening and weekend. Because I have found that it is true that we all function
at our best when we know what is going to come next and what is expected
of us. It helps to set a certain time for the less attractive subjects
like grammar, foreign language and math. After that type of learning is
out of the way for the day then the field trips and pottery can occur,
guilt free.
Short lessons motivate the child to finish because he knows that there
is not much time to complete his assignment. This helps to keep the child
alert. This is particularly helpful when dealing with the child’s least
favorite subject. It’s sort of the “eat-your-spinach” concept. If he doesn’t
like it, at least he knows once it is finished he won’t be asked to do
it again until tomorrow.
I’ve never seen this advice in any of Charlotte Mason’s books, but I know
from personal experience that some people, both young and old, are motivated
by being able to cross tasks off a list, or drawing a line through the
completed assignment of the planning book. Some parents like to use the
motivational charts that are sold at teacher stores, which include the
use of stickers. Even if this has never appealed to you, there is a chance
that one of your children might be highly motivated by the satisfaction
of filling in a chart or crossing assignments off the list.
What we can know is that Charlotte did recommend the use of natural rewards.
The example she gives in Home Education on page 143 is of a child being
allowed twenty minutes to complete his math. If he gets it done quickly
and correctly then the “natural consequence[s] of his good conduct” is
that he has a few minutes of leisure time. Charlotte says that he can choose
any activity including a quick trip outside or drawing. I don’t necessarily
send my kids out to the yard right in the middle of short lessons but I
do give the remainder of the allotted time to draw or work a crossword
puzzle or whatever they like to do. In fact, I keep that type of fun yet
quiet stuff near them so they can pick it up and occupy themselves while
other children are still finishing.
The older the child becomes the more we expect him to pay attention, therefore,
we want to keep working at the habit of attention slowly but surely. Help
them with this by seeing it as your job as the home schooling parent. Try
to make sure that your “child never does a lesson into which he does not
put his heart.” (Vol. 1, p. 146 ) This will build the habit of finishing
that Charlotte writes about in Ourselves. One of my favorite quotes of
hers is, “What is worth beginning is worth finishing, and what is worth
doing is worth doing well.” (Vol. 4, pt. II, p. 172) She knows it’s tempting
to start something new, but she insists that “It is worth while to make
ourselves go on with the thing we are doing until it is finished.”
To use natural consequences to our benefit we sometimes need to set up
a somewhat artificial situation. If dragging out math time has become the
biggest problem of your entire day then wait and do math right before the
child’s favorite television show comes on or a few minutes before all the
neighborhood children show up to play basketball in front of your house.
Show him or her the exact math problems you want done. Be clear about how
much time there is to do them whether it is fifteen minutes or sixty. Then
if, and only if, he gets his math done and done right does he go ahead
and do the activity he has been wanting to do. Another thing that works
for extreme cases is to set up a chess board, some clay, whatever his current
passion is and have it there on the table next to him but out of reach.
Yes, you may have to play a game of chess with your child in the middle
of the day, but hopefully it will not be long until he sees the benefits
of short lessons for himself.
The goal is not bribery. The goal is to teach “real life” and in real life
we sometimes have to do things we do not want to do. I do not enjoy computing
my annual taxes at all but there are consequences already in place if I
do not file them by a certain well-known date each year. I can keep dreading
the day and put off the necessary preparation work or I can get it done
and not have to face that chore for an entire year. Even better is the
feeling of having it off my mind so that it does not weigh on me mentally.
In addition, we have a responsibility to provide very interesting materials
for the children to learn from. Once the life lesson is learned and the
habits are established then you will find that it is the materials themselves
that motivate a child to stay focused and finish the school day. I’m not
suggesting that you remain stuck in anything that resembles bribery.
If your best efforts still leave you with a dawdler on your hands then
it may be a case of obstinate refusal to cooperate. If after sufficient
motivation and interesting school work has been provided you are still
frustrated then try considering it a discipline problem and handle it as
such. That would mean dealing with the problem in whatever manner with
which you usually train your children when they have directly defied your
authority.
I have devoted an entire article to parenting for the website so I will
not go into detail at this time but I will leave one quick suggestion that
has worked for me. I sometimes use the demerit system at our house. It
is a lot like receiving a speeding ticket in that it is simply a piece
of paper, but it is what the paper represents and the fact that you got
one written about you. Have you ever pled with a police officer upon being
pulled over? Well, the children have the same reaction; they want to get
out of the demerit and will usually stop misbehaving and start doing what
you asked. What consequences should a demerit hold? Be creative. Taking
away a privilege usually works with children, but you do have to use what
works for the individual.
Do not make using short lessons more complicated for yourself than it has
to be. It can be very simple, and it allows you to get around to all those
really good books, art prints and music you’ve collected. It allows you
to go on a field trip or a trip to the beach guilt free. It is really only
a matter of a written schedule created by you to fit your daily life. Couple
that with a simple kitchen timer and give it a chance. You may find what
I found, children positively loving the ticking of the timer just as if
they were on a game show. Children thriving by knowing exactly what is
being asked of them. And most importantly, children knowing that a fast
paced morning with interesting materials leads right into a relaxed afternoon.
As a parent you may find the sense of satisfaction that comes from not
neglecting certain subjects and be pleasantly surprised by how much more
time you have to do what you want to do. Most of all I hope you’ll discover
the happiness of retention. If you are going to spend that much time each
day and ultimately that many years with your children it would be very
satisfying to know that they had learned to concentrate and they were able
to hold on to some lasting knowledge.
Catherine Levison
Adapted from the “Realistic Charlotte Mason”
Column
Originally printed in The Link Homeschooling
Newspaper
Copyright 2006
